A recent study has unveiled that short bursts of physical activity, like brisk walking or climbing stairs, may be significantly more effective for weight loss than traditional workouts. These brief exercises can burn 20% to 60% more energy than sustained activities over the same distance. Conducted on individuals aged 18-45, the study highlights that the body might be preparing for these bursts, although further research is necessary to fully comprehend the underlying mechanisms.
The study’s methodology involved using an oxygen mask to measure oxygen uptake and metabolic cost. It discovered that 30-second spurts of activity had a greater metabolic cost, consuming significantly more oxygen compared to steady exercise. Despite these findings, Jordan Garrett, the study’s lead author, cautioned that the higher energy expenditure is contingent upon specific circumstances.
“The study implies HIIT could burn more calories due to frequent stopping and starting, but it’s not conclusive. While HIIT can be effective, the benefit over traditional workouts might not be as significant for everyone.” – Unspecified
The research emphasizes the potential cognitive benefits of short bursts of activity, noting improvements in memory and executive functions. Barry Giesbrecht, the senior author, stated that understanding exercise’s impact on cognitive function is crucial. Yet, because the study focused on exercise durations between 10 seconds and 4 minutes, its conclusions are limited and cannot be broadly applied to all workout forms.
“We have to keep in mind that this study only looked at very short exercise durations, those between 10 seconds and 4 minutes. We can’t necessarily apply this concept to longer durations.” – Christopher A. Schneble, MD
The study’s results suggest that vigorous activities may have the most substantial effects on cognitive functions. Garrett mentioned that these findings align with previous research on short bursts’ benefits. However, Giesbrecht noted that the enhancements might be minimal since they are often measured when the physical activity isn’t directly related to a cognitive task.
“What I found particularly interesting was that regardless of the activity, there was an initial over intake of oxygen more often in excess of the eventual intake required downstream. To some degree, this could be our bodies doing their best to put us in a situation to be ‘overprepared’ for bursts of physical activity, but a lot more research is needed to get down to the bottom of this and understand what drives this finding.” – Christopher A. Schneble, MD
The researchers acknowledge that their findings are limited to the specific population studied, and more investigation is needed to evaluate short bursts’ weight loss effects in other demographics. Additionally, age-related differences remain unexplored, leaving questions about whether younger individuals with higher energy levels benefit less from such activities than older adults.
“The study doesn’t explore age-related differences, so it’s unclear if younger people, with higher energy levels, gain less from short bursts than older adults.” – Unspecified
Despite these limitations, the study offers valuable insights into maximizing exercise efficiency through brief but intense activities, particularly for beginners embarking on their fitness journey. However, as Ryan Glatt points out, the actual benefits may vary based on individual metabolism and exercise habits.
“While shorter bursts might burn more calories, the actual benefit may vary depending on individual metabolism and exercise habits.” – Ryan Glatt, CPT, NBC-HWC
Featured image made on Ideogram
Leave a Reply