The Netflix series “Nobody Wants This” has been renewed for a second season, stirring both excitement and controversy. The show, created by Erin Foster, who converted to Judaism herself, delves into her personal experiences during her courtship and conversion. However, its portrayal of Judaism has drawn criticism, with some labeling it as “mildly antisemitic.” The show’s new direction is now under the helm of Bruce Eric Kaplan and Jenni Konner, both acclaimed for their work on HBO’s comedy “Girls.”
The series follows the story of Noah, a charismatic rabbi, and his non-Jewish girlfriend, Joanne, as they navigate the complexities of faith and identity. Critics argue that the show perpetuates outdated stereotypes about modern Jews, such as portraying them as overbearing and overly concerned with money. Additionally, the use of the term “shiksa” to describe non-Jewish women has been called offensive and antiquated.
Erin Foster, who based the show on her own journey, has faced backlash for the portrayal of Judaism as inflexible and lacking nuance. Critics suggest that the show fails to explore the richness and diversity within Judaism, instead opting for a more rigid depiction. In response to the criticism, Foster has expressed her personal connection to the narrative.
“She liked being encouraged to doubt and ask questions, she liked that their rabbi told them their discussions during the car ride home were the most important part of conversion, and she particularly liked hearing that converts were closest to God.” – Erin Foster
Despite its intention to provide a humorous take on religious conversion, the series’ comedic approach has been perceived as uncomfortable and off-putting. Some critics have described the humor as “tired and misanthropic,” contributing to an overall tone that is seen as negative and cynical.
The portrayal of characters in “Nobody Wants This” has also raised eyebrows. Many are depicted as unhappy, with their connections to Judaism portrayed as superficial and tied more closely to social standing than genuine faith. This depiction has led to accusations of cynicism, particularly in how Joanne’s character remains unchallenged in her skeptical views.
Moreover, the show’s treatment of relationship podcasters Joanne and her sister Morgan has been criticized for being disdainful and unrealistic. Critics argue that their roles are trivialized, further contributing to the show’s perceived negativity.
Noah Roklov, the “Hot Rabbi” character, embodies the struggle with faith that many viewers might relate to.
“Wrestling with what God is or isn’t, not knowing.” – Noah Roklov
This exploration of faith could have offered depth to the series; however, critics argue that it falls short due to its lack of optimism and hopefulness.
As Bruce Eric Kaplan and Jenni Konner take over as showrunners and executive producers for the upcoming season, there is anticipation about whether they will address these criticisms. Their previous work on “Girls” suggests they could bring a fresh perspective and potentially reshape the narrative.
Featured Image courtesy of Telegram.hr
Leave a Reply